Saturday, January 30, 2016

Upgrade to a Garmin 235 if you already have a 620, or just cheap out on a Vivosmart HR?

This question was posed on the latest version (Episode 32) of The DCR Podcast: is it worth upgrading to a 235 from a 620? Ray Maker thought it made sense to just buy a Vivosmart HR and use that with the 620 instead of upgrading. I usually see eye to eye with Ray, but on this one, unlike Ben Hobbs, I really don't think he's right here.

First off -- cost. 

The Vivosmart HR is $150. So in that sense, it is certainly cheaper than going out and buying a 235 for $329.  Is the 235 worth an extra $180?  

I would have thought a 620 in pretty good shape would have sold for close to $100 on eBay, but the market seems thin - I only saw one used device getting bid on - and it was only up to $30. So it isn't prudent at this point to expect the 620 retains a ton of value.

I think there's real value in the 235 over the 620 + Vivosmart HR. Here's my list:

- A better accelerometer for indoor treadmill running.  I find the 235 to nail it as well as a Garmin footpod (which retails for $70) when I run inside -- more accurate (closer to perceived pace and actual pace on treadmill display) than any other Garmin I've owned. My Vivosmart HR was unusually bad on this count - 20% off the actual count in miles. If you do a lot of treadmilling, this accuracy is a significant feature.  The pace and HR below are from a treadmill 5K.

- It looks more like a watch than a running watch.  The 620 watchface and color scheme weren't business friendly - I like a watch that isn't noticed as a running watch. The 235 is black, sleek, and is not noticeable as a running watch.  

- Garmin Connect IQ watch faces. There are some really functional and even approaching attractive free watch faces on the storefront (and a bunch of other widgets to play with). If you like gadgets and fiddling with this kind of thing, it's a lot of fun.

- One watch to rule them all. It's a lot better to have one device to charge and wear, rather than a band and a running watch - much more convenient.

So there you have it.  I'd say if you are a regular runner, it's a no-brainer - go upgrade. Welcome to 2016.


  1. Michael Kors Handbags Outlet is known for its quality and the price speaks for that kind of quality.
    Look for Michael Kors Bags Outlet which has been operating for quite a period of time and has good feedback and reviews.
    You can also go for Michael Kors Outlet Online shopping.

  2. Check out the seller's feedback rating to know if they have built a good reputation in selling discount Coach Handbag Clearance. Because of this, shoppers are on the lookout for more places offering discount Coach 25 Off Coupon. The problem now is determining whether or not to buy your Coach Outlet Online 80 Off, at a thrift store or at a traditional brick and mortar location. (tags: Michael Kors Handbags Macys,Macys Michael Kors Handbags Sale,Michael Kors Handbags On Sale Outlet)

    It is just as important to arm yourself with knowledge about how to determine whether or not your Coach Store Locator is real or a replica because outside of purchasing one from a Coach Outlet Online Clearance or a Coach Factory Online Sale Invitation, there are no guarantees.(tags: Coach Leather Handbags,Michael Kors Clearance Bags,Coach Outlet Website)